A freelance editor once told me that in the world of writers there are plotters and there are free stylists. Plotters start with an outline in hand, marching through prose and dialogue until they arrive at an ending conceived on a whiteboard or napkin long before. Free stylists– that’s me– start with a character (if they’re lucky) or a sentence (if they’re not), and are as shocked as their readers will some day be by what happens. I once posted, “My character is making a terrible choice; I can’t believe I’m letting it happen. Hope there’s no such thing as character karma.” For me, that’s how it goes down. I get to know these people– their strengths, their weaknesses, their predilections– and then conflict presents itself.
I’m not a martyr. I WISH I COULD PLOT. I want to. I tried desperately to follow that path with my second book. I don’t consider it cheating or even corner-cutting; I’m just unable to get scenes on paper when I already know how it plays out. It’s as if my inner muse loses interest. So, instead, I take the hardest possible route: writing to find the story, then cutting to pace it.
Last year I attached a sail to a new character and eventually found my next novel, WHATEVER HAPPENED TO LUCY BISCARO?, about a woman whose past keeps meddling with her future. It went to my editor a month ago. We met in New York last week to discuss the revision. I received an A on the writing and characters, but a B- on pacing. Lucy has a happy home at St. Martin’s Press just as soon as I get her to the ending faster. This time, publishing’s pace will work in my favor. Readers won’t meet Lucy until February 2018, so I have time to build her up.
Other writers: are you a plotter or a free stylist? A hybrid, perhaps? Tips to share?
Abby, I am having the same issue with my second novel that you described with yours — “I’m just unable to get scenes on paper when I already know how it plays out. It’s as if my inner muse loses interest.” My first novel was character driven, and the plot just had to emerge, because I do like a decent plot. I’m not abandoning my outline yet, but I’m trying to forget it as much as possible. Congratulations on novels #1 and #2!
Good luck! I sat down with an outline and ended up writing a completely different story. Yours will find you I’m sure!!
I was a pantser before I ever heard the term — maybe before it was even coined.
I remember a friend called me one day, maybe around 1975, and asked “Do you write with the front of your brain?” Without even thinking, I responded, “No, I write by the seat of my pants.”
Like you, if I know where a story is going, I lose interest in actually writing it.
I think once you bow to your process it’s easier. At least with book three I won’t waste time trying to outline 🙂
I am such a Type A person I always assumed I would need to plan out the whole story before I started writing it. With each of the three books I’ve written, I’ve started by sitting down and trying to plan out every scene, and every time I’ve given up at some point and just started to write the damn thing. It took me awhile to accept that THIS is my process. I need to outline the first few chapters and then start writing, and as I write I figure out what I want to happen for the next few chapters, etc. So I guess I am a combo – I need a bit of a roadmap but one that’s flexible enough so the characters can switch course!
Love that there’s no right way. It’s been fun to get to know writers more personally this year and see how unique the process really is for everyone 🙂
I am just amazed to learn about the process through your experiences. Thank you for including me in your journey. xo
There’d be no journey without you lady 🙂
It’s funny, I’ve known you for a long time and I never would have pegged you for a pantser. Great post!!
Me neither! If every other way in life I’m a plotter/planner … wish I had your mad outlining skills 🙂
Her mad outlining skills really are something. They’ve helped me a ton.
MIKE! So excited to meet you someday. I plan to call you Monday for some plot advice 🙂
I hear so much about you, I feel like I know you!
And please do give me a call — happy to do anything I can to help.
Aww, thanks. You guys are making me blush. 🙂
Such a meaningful compliment, coming from two of my favorite writers.